|
You'll
find on this page information we've been accumulating about the
Carl Schumann Porcelain Factory of
Arzberg, Bavaria, Germany.
We undertook this project a few years ago as a
service in response to the many questions we started receiving about Schumann.
In fact, at this point, it has taken on a life of its own and has grown far
beyond anything we expected. We literally receive numerous e-mails
from various parts of the world on a daily basis about Schumann. We
welcome those e-mails and appreciate each and every one of you who send us your
family stories and pictures of your beautiful Schumann. We've even
heard from a few families who (both they and their Schumann)
thankfully survived Hurricane Katrina. Thanks to each of you for
sharing your family history and experiences.
As we
progress and learn more, we
continue to research, revise our opinions, and update this
information. Please remember this is only an
attempt to piece together an ongoing puzzle and nothing is guaranteed or
set in stone. Please forgive any mistakes in our assumptions, as I'm
quite certain there are many.
Please contact us if you can help in the least
way.
We welcome
all e-mails, even if it's just to say you appreciate what you have found
and have learned from it -- we've received many, many such comments.
Thank you. Knowing that we have helped others in some small way makes
worthwhile all the many hours, days, months, and
years that we have devoted to this project.
Scroll
down this page for our ongoing comments which we have tried to group in
logical order by topic, beginning with
Factory Dates. Following our ongoing general comments, you will
eventually come to our Tables of Schumann Marks
and Patterns, which we hope you find to be a good
visual for researching your Schumann.
Read on -- we hope you find
this as interesting as we have.
The
Schumann Factory was
first established in 1881
in Arzberg, Bavaria, Germany, and finally ceased production in
1994. Early in our
research, we found a
German website and have e-mail communication that confirms the
1994 closing date (see
footnotes 6 and 7 below).
Although the factory shut down in
1994, a Schumann
factory outlet stayed open for approximately another 10 years in Arzberg,
apparently
for the purpose of selling off what was left of the Schumann inventory.
We are told that the outlet finally closed in 2004
or early 2005 -- a sad
final note in the history of this great old porcelain factory.(54)
Ebeling & Reuss of Philadelphia/ Devon/Allentown, Pennsylvania,
were the
exclusive American importers of
Schumann
beginning in the
late 1940's. We do have
indication that they imported Schumann under the name
Erphila prior
to World War II (back into the 1930's
or even earlier) but we don't know if they were exclusive
importers at that time.
We have in our possession
an assortment of old
E & R
brochures, ads, and pamphlets from the
late 1940's, 1950's, and 1960s, all
of which have been tremendously helpful in dating some of the
Schumann patterns.
The
E & R
ads
from the
late 1940's
are
advertising the many Schumann patterns they were importing at that time. The
earliest ad we have is dated
January 1948 and is promising
immediate delivery after January 1,
1948, although this ad does not specify the
particular patterns to be imported.
However, an
August 1949 E & R
ad is advertising specific patterns,
including the popular
Empress Dresden and
Chateau Dresden.
The ad is also identifying them as being made in
U. S. Zone Germany,
which is
referring to the years 1945-49
when Bavaria was occupied by the U. S. after the end of World War II. We
don't know what mark, if any, E & R
was using at that time. We have yet to find an
E & R
mark of any kind on any of the
U. S. Zone
pieces.
For
example, we have direct information regarding
a set of
Empress that was purchased brand new in
1948
in
Pennsylvania,
though not necessarily through
E & R
-- the exact origin of purchase is unknown to the
current family member, although it does seem logical that
E & R
might have been the source.(59) That set does not have
an
E & R
mark at all, but is marked
U. S. Zone.
Either E & R
was not marking at that time, or the set came into
the U.S. through another channel (see
**
paragraphs in the
American Market
section below for possible options, as well as Footnote 2C found
after the Table of Marks below).
The
E & R blue Golden Crown mark,
frequently found on Schumann china, was apparently not
used until the 1950's.
It is shown in reference books as having been put into use beginning in
1955. However, we have a copy of an
Ebeling & Reuss pamphlet dated
1954 which came with a set of
Schumann Platinum Elegance purchased new in
1954 and does have the
Golden Crown mark (see footnote 15 below),
although the pamphlet itself does not illustrate the mark. Whether
or not the Golden Crown
mark goes back any further than 1954, we don't know.
As to how long the
E & R blue Golden
Crown mark was used on Schumann China, the
DMA (Dallas
Museum of Art book discussed in American Market
section below), page 289, says that
E & R dropped many of its
European lines in 1976
because of economic issues in Europe, as well as economic problems within
E & R itself. We
are therefore adjusting our dates accordingly and assume that any
Schumann with the E & R mark
is dated 1976 or earlier,
although actual distribution to the public might not have occurred until
much later, as inferred in Footnotes 3A
and 38
below.
E &
R imported other product lines besides
Schumann and did use a variety of marks back through the years. As
already mentioned earlier in this section, we
know they were importing European wares prior to World War II under the name
Erphila,
but we're not sure if they
imported Schumann
at that time. We have suspected that they
did and now have evidence indicating that might have been the case -- read
Footnote 86
below.
If
any one of you out there has anything, Schumann or
otherwise, with
E & R marks of any
kind that you can date (through family history or otherwise) prior
to 1955, please e-mail us.
Ebeling & Reuss
is still in business today in Pennsylvania, but has been purchased by a
large corporation. We have tried unsuccessfully to find a current
and working e-mail or phone number for
E & R,
so if anyone
can help with that, please let us know.
(More comments about
E & R in the
American Market
section below)
|
Some of the More Popular Patterns |
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
OLD Dresden (straight
edge solid rim) |
Empress
Dresden (scalloped edge solid rim) |
Chateau
Dresden (scalloped edge reticulated rim) |
Forget-Me-Not (scalloped edge solid rim) |
Chalet
Forget-Me-Not (scalloped edge reticulated rim) |
We have come to believe that pattern names,
with or without the E & R
importer's
mark, were probably added by the Schumann factory for the American market only. As you study
the table of marks below, you'll see numerous examples of pattern names
that were obviously added after-the-fact. Many appear to be older
pre-existing pieces that were most likely manufactured pre-1945 but not
distributed until after the war ended in 1945.
Regarding some of the more popular Schumann patterns, we believe the Chateau
Dresden pattern
ceased (read more below)
in the
1960's and the
Empress Dresden pattern in the
1980's (we have
communicated with someone who purchased a complete set of new Empress
in the early 1980's from a local jewelry store who had to
special order the set directly from the factory in Germany).
The
*Chateau Dresden and
*Chalet Forget-Me-Not patterns
are
shown in the
1961 E& R
brochure, but are
both
missing from the
1965-66 brochure, which indicates that the
Chateau and
Chalet patterns most likely did
cease production
somewhere
between 1961 and
1965.
*Chateau
is the reticulated (pierced rim) version of the
Dresden Flowers and is complementary to the
Empress solid rim dinnerware.
*Chalet is the reticulated
(pierced rim) version of the Forget-Me-Not
and is complementary to the FMN
solid rim dinnerware.
We
have
no information so far about the actual beginning dates for any of these
patterns, except our marks shown below, as well as our old
E & R ads, show that the
Empress Dresden
and Chateau Dresden
patterns,
as well as the
Chalet Forget-Me-Not all go back at least as far as the
1940's
when the
U. S. Zone mark was used (1945-1949,
the years when the U.S. occupied Bavaria, Germany, just after World War II).
At this point, we believe
that the
Empress and Chateau were both in existence
prior to
1945,
although they might not yet have been named as such. Just how far
back the
Empress
actually goes, we don't know. As for the
Chateau, we have bought and sold numerous "Chateau"
pieces that were clearly
Chateau
and clearly, based on the marks, from the
1920's-30's era,
but were not identified as
Chateau.
The more we study the marks, the more we are convinced of the
pre-1945
existence of both patterns. In fact, in support of our belief are the old
E & R ads
of 1949
which refer to both Empress and Chateau
as being "...generations old, yet
ever appealing..." Empress
is also referred to as "...truly
Schumann's Masterpiece..." and
"Carl Schumann's famous old-world Dresden decoration -- never changed since
it was first introduced generations ago....our finest pattern..."
The
Forget-Me-Not solid rim
version
(not Chalet) is yet another mystery.(3A, 21,
38) Our oldest
documentation for it is the
December 1952 E & R
ad which shows it among the patterns available at that time. We
believe it probably goes back even further.
We don't know for certain how long the it was in
production, although we know it was still in production into the
1960's. Our two
old
E & R pamphlets,
one dated
1961 and one dated
1965-66,
both
show the
Forget-Me-Not
solid rim
as being
one of Schumann's "latest masterpieces." We've also heard from a couple who purchased a brand new
set in
1980(38);
we believe that set was probably old inventory and probably
no newer than around 1976.
As
mentioned above, E & R
dropped many of its European lines in 1976
because of economic issues, so we assume that any Schumann with the
E & R
mark is
no newer than around 1976,
regardless of how long it took to reach the end consumer.
|
Schumann Red Crown Mark
(see Table of
Marks below) |
The
red crown mark
and all of its many variations has turned into quite a challenge all by itself as to
exactly when it may have first been used by Schumann.
However, we do have a few developments:
(1)We have indication that one form of the red crown mark (with
only the words "Schumann Bavaria") was
apparently used as far back as
1918. This
belief is based on information from Kenny Sugarman of
Douglas, Arizona. He has in his possession a portrait plate (shown
below in our table of patterns) that was handed down to him from his
father; Kenny's father received the plate directly from an aunt and uncle
who told him it was one of their wedding gifts; he said they were married
in New York somewhere around 1918 -- they are basing this
date on the age
of the oldest child of that couple.
That portrait plate has the red crown mark.
Kenny, thanks to both you and your father for this helpful
information!!
(2)In support of Kenny's
information above, Barb VanderRoest of Amherst Nova
Scotia Canada, also has a beautiful portrait plate (shown
below in our table of patterns) similar to Kenny's and with the
same red crown
mark with only the
words "Schumann Bavaria." It is the surviving plate of
a pair that originally belonged to her grandmother in Nova Scotia.
Barb's mother, born in 1920,
remembers the plates as a very young child. She was told that she
broke the second plate when she was a toddler. Barb, thanks
for being willing to share such interesting and valuable information!!
(3)We have
also heard from a lady who has some Schumann
Wild Rose Blush pieces with the
red crown mark
and only the words Wild Rose and
Schumann
Arzberg Germany.
They were given to her in 1983 by a client who was then in her 80's and
said they were from
pre-war Germany and that she inherited them
from her mother who was from Germany. This helps to further verify
the older age of the red crown mark.
(4)Yet
another piece of information is from Dmitry in Brooklyn, New York, who has
a set of an early version of the
Wild Rose
pattern with the
red crown mark. They
originally belonged to a lady who fled Nazi Germany in the
1930's and
brought the dishes with her at that time.
As you study the
red marks
(as well as the others) in
the tables below, you'll see that I have tried to group them as much as
possible according to the various combinations of words of origin in the mark. For example, (1)Bavaria;
(2)Bavaria Germany; (3)Germany;
(4)Arzberg Bavaria; (5)Arzberg
Bavaria Germany; and so on -- you see how complicated this
is. As you will notice below, even the placement and order
of the same words vary from mark to mark. Why such inconsistency???
-- we don't know.
Notice also that the words
are either (1) part of the original mark; or (2) were
added at a late time. For those that were obviously
added at a later time, I have displayed them in contrasting
colors to make it easier in trying to study and distinguish the
differences in the marks and the progression of their use.
In summary, I have tried to
organize all the marks in priority order by (1)Style;
(2)Color; (3)Words; (4)Order of Words;
(5)Placement of Words; (6)circa Dates.
A little summary of
Bavarian History which I have
read from a variety of sources might be helpful and is the basis for
many of my dating assumptions about the wide variety of Schumann marks,
many of which seem to have overlapped with one another as to years of use:
1918-1933 = Bavaria independent from Germany following WW I
1933-1945 = Bavaria lost independence to Nazi Germany
1945-49 = Bavaria in U. S. Zone of Germany following WW II
1949-1990 = Bavaria part of West Germany**
1990-Present = Germany reunited
Bavaria is currently the largest state in Germany.
**Germany was divided into East and West
in 1949 following World War II.
FRG = Federal Republic of Germany (West
Germany)
GDR = German Democratic Republic (East
Germany)
(Source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West Germany and
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German Democratic Republic)
As I
learn more, I continue to make revisions. I also continue to ask such questions as -- why did
Schumann have so many different versions of marks and why did they
apparently overlap with one another??; what do the numbers
mean?? This continues to
be complicated
and intriguing. You will see that I continue to add many
notations along with the marks; I do that just as much for myself as
for my viewers.
|
World War II, Military, American Market |
One
thing you will notice are my comments that some words (U.S.
Zone for example, as well as pattern names) were obviously added
to pre-existing pieces -- inferring that there were pieces that survived the
war. Before you immediately say that everything was destroyed in the
war, I had e-mail communication with someone a few years ago who had
incredible knowledge of Schumann and how they managed to protect
their china during the war. I won't go into detail here because I have
lost touch with that person (the e-mail is no longer active). If you are reading this and you are
that person, please e-mail me.
I have withheld pertinent details here which only
you will know. I will maintain your confidentiality if you
wish, or credit you here with your permission, Please contact
me.
I have also
communicated with someone who told me about being stationed in Germany
during the early 1950's and
buying Dresden from a shop owner who told him that many of the Dresden
pieces just then coming on the market had been crated and buried during
World War II in order to protect them. He told me he bought the
pieces to ship back to the U.S. for his mother. His information has
confirmed what I suggested in the footnotes below about the possibility of
Schumann entering the U.S. through the military, even into the 1950's,
thereby bypassing importers and retailers and their related marks.** He
has also reconfirmed what I just discussed above about porcelain pieces
having survived the war and distributed later.
**In
support of the previous paragraph, we now have a wonderful book (already
mentioned in another paragraph above) from the
Dallas Museum of Art called
"China and Glass in America, 1880-1980,
From Tabletop to TV Tray." Page 231 of this book discusses the large volumes of fine quality
china that were distributed through the Military PX's in Germany beginning
just after the end of World War II and continuing through the 1950's.
This method bypassed the American importers and retailers and also their
related marks. However, in 1961, the U S. government started requiring the PXs
to go through American importers to acquire their products.
**Page
231 also discusses another option for entry of Schumann china into
the U.S. -- through the Department of Commerce and a special
division called U. S. Commercial Company (USCC) which was
created specifically for the purpose of exporting 50%
of the porcelain production of Germany. The U. S. was the primary
consumer of that 50%. The remaining 50% of Germany's porcelain
production was divided between the U. S. Military PX's (25%)
and the German citizens (25%). (Source:
"China and Glass in America, 1880-1980,
From Tabletop to TV Tray" by the
Dallas Museum of Art, page 231)
Also
of interest in the book is page 289 which is devoted to a lengthy discussion of the
importer Ebeling and Reuss.
We don't know if the USCC worked through
E & R or independent of
them. Perhaps E & R took
up where the USCC ended -- we don't know. What we do
know is that E & R was
importing Schumann china as
least as early as January 1, 1948,
as documented by our old E & R
ads and which we have already discussed several paragraphs above.
If you wish to purchase this book, it's available through the
DMA Museum Store. This book is well worth the
money and gives a great insight into the history of china in America and
the European connection.
As to who marketed
Schumann to the end-consumer in the U.S., we have interesting e-mails with
information that Schumann was apparently being sold by Marshall Field
in Chicago and Gump's in San Francisco as far back as the 1930's.(76)
We also now know that Alfred Orlik
had a shop on Madison Avenue in New York
as early as 1940 and perhaps
earlier. We have an October 1940
issue of House Beautiful magazine
with an Alfred Orlik ad for an
English breakfast set. The
Orlik name in the ad is in the
exact same style as the one found on hand painted
Schumann
Forget-Me-Not plates that have the Schumann U. S. Zone mark
which dates to 1945-1949. Apparently
Orlik was a china retailer
before and after World War II. Just how long he was in
business, we don't yet know. No doubt other high-end department stores, jewelry stores,
and china shops across the country were also marketers for Schumann.
We have recently received information that J. C.
Penney was yet another retail source for Schumann in the
1950's.
Prior
to World War II, Schumann acted as its own importer and distributor and
operated 1931-1941 under the name
Schumann China Corporation of New York.
According to the DMA book
mentioned above, Schumann was sold under the brand names "Dresdner Art
China" and "Schumann Bavaria" during those years of
1931-1941.
As to how Schumann was imported and distributed
prior to 1931, we don't yet know.
After
the war, E & R became the
exclusive U.
S. importer of Schumann with showrooms in New York,
Philadelphia, Chicago, and Los Angeles. They eventually added
showrooms in Dallas, Atlanta, Denver, Minneapolis, Cleveland, and Detroit.
Warehouses were in Philadelphia and Pasadena.
Anyone who can add additional
information is welcome to
e-mail
us to help make this more accurate and complete. Friendly,
helpful e-mails are always welcome. Thanks to each of you who
continue to write to us with additional pieces to this puzzle. We
will credit you by name, city, state, and country unless you request
otherwise. If you wish to remain anonymous, we will honor that
request.
More
information on the way as we have time!!
Copyright Notice
All photographs on this page, unless
otherwise noted, as well as photographs on
the rest of our website were made by us from actual pieces we currently
own or have owned in the past and may not be copied or used by others without our
prior permission.**
Copyright 2000-2007 and beyond
All Rights Reserved
Efineantiques, Sharon Dickinson, and Sharon Dickinson Fine
Antiques
Submissions and Permission
**For
research purposes, we
do accept and post selected pictures of marks and patterns
which have been contributed to us by others. Those pictures are also
protected under our copyright notice. Appropriate credits have been
given in our footnotes.
By your submission, you are granting us permission to publish your pictures, information, and questions
should we so choose and as we so choose
unless you inform us otherwise at the time of your submission. Please be sure to tell us how you
would like to be acknowledged for your contributions -- by full name or by
initials only, or even anonymous, although we do prefer first and last
names in this particular section. We also like to know your general
location such as city, state, country, region, etc. We will honor
your wishes and appreciate your help.
|